Reviewed by Buying an investment property can look straightforward on paper: find a promising property, run the numbers, make an offer, and start generating income. In reality, experienced investors know there are plenty of variables that don’t always make it into the initial spreadsheet.
When you’re buying your first real estate investment property – whether it’s a house in Seattle, WA or a property in Jackson, WY – understanding the less obvious risks and responsibilities can help you evaluate a deal more realistically. From unexpected expenses to local market nuances, here’s what to know before buying an investment property.
Key takeaways
- A property can look appealing but still be a poor investment if the purchase price, expenses, financing, or expected income don’t work together.
- Account for costs beyond the mortgage, including taxes, insurance, maintenance, vacancies, property management, and renovations.
- Don’t rely on appreciation alone. Run the numbers based on realistic income, expenses, and market conditions.
- Research the local market, regulations, financing requirements, and renovation risks before committing to a property.
- Decide how hands-on you want to be and whether you’ll need help from property managers, contractors, or other professionals.
1. A good property isn’t automatically a good investment
A well-maintained home may seem like a safe investment, but the property itself is only part of the equation. The purchase price, potential income, operating expenses, financing, and your investment strategy all affect whether a deal makes sense.
“Patience may be one of the most valuable lessons experienced real estate investors could share,” says James P. Schlimmer of the Equity Trust Company. “Buying a home is emotional, but experienced investors tend to remain disciplined and let the numbers help guide their decisions. Look beyond the asking price and pay attention to signals such as cumulative days on market, price reductions, and the seller’s circumstances. The longer a property has been available, the more opportunity there may be to have a thoughtful negotiation rather than letting emotion dictate the offer.”
2. Your expenses will go beyond the mortgage
One of the biggest lessons for new investors is how quickly smaller ownership expenses can add up. A mortgage payment may be the most obvious cost, but it shouldn’t be the only number in your calculations.
Depending on the property and investment strategy, expenses could include:
- Property taxes and insurance
- Maintenance and repairs
- Property management
- Utilities and landscaping
- HOA dues
- Vacancy periods
- Renovations and capital improvements
Build some breathing room into your projections rather than assuming everything will go according to plan. A property that only works financially under ideal conditions may leave little room for an unexpected repair or longer-than-anticipated vacancy.
>>Read: Buying a Second Home vs Investment Property: A Side-by-Side Comparison Guide
3. Look beyond appreciation when running numbers
Property values can rise over time, but appreciation isn’t guaranteed.
“When I bought my first investment property, I put a lot of research into choosing what I thought was the right market, and that served me well,” says Stephen Keighery of the New Orleans Real Estate Investors Association. “What I learned over time, though, is that I don’t want to rely on the market going up to make a good return. The old saying that ‘you make your money when you buy’ really is true. Today, I focus much more on buying distressed properties at a price where I can add value, so the potential equity is created when I buy rather than depending on future appreciation.”
Before investing, use comparable homes and calculate additional expenses to assess your property’s potential value. Whether you’re planning to rent out the property or renovate for a resale, planning ahead for fluctuations in rental income or market conditions can give you a better picture of how much risk you’re taking on.
4. Real estate investing is highly local
A strategy that works well in one city may not translate to another. Rental demand, property taxes, insurance costs, permitting requirements, landlord-tenant regulations, short-term rental restrictions, and other factors can vary considerably by location.
Before buying, research both the broader housing market and the immediate neighborhood. Look at comparable rents and sales, vacancy trends, employment and population patterns, and the types of properties renters or buyers are seeking.
Just as importantly, learn the rules that apply to your intended use of the property. Never assume that because another investor uses a particular strategy elsewhere, you’ll be able to do the same.
“Take time to get educated,” urges the Mid-Atlantic Real Estate Investors Association. “Real estate investment requires financial and legal information that, if not obtained, can result in major problems. New real estate investors should find their local real estate investor association (REIA) to connect with other local investors.”
5. Renovations rarely go exactly according to plan
A fixer-upper can create an opportunity to add value, but renovation estimates deserve scrutiny. What initially looks like a cosmetic project can uncover aging plumbing, electrical issues, structural concerns, permitting requirements, or other costly surprises.
Consider getting appropriate inspections and contractor estimates before finalizing your budget. Then account for the possibility that the project could cost more or take longer than expected.
“A red flag is a reason to investigate further, and it doesn’t automatically mean you should walk away,” explains Chris Borden, president of the Utah Real Estate Investors Association. “Many property issues can be addressed by negotiating the price, setting aside more money, or allowing more time. The key is understanding what you’re buying, what it will take to address the problems, and whether the return still makes sense. Look beyond the building, too: if local rental demand depends heavily on one employer or industry, renovating the property won’t fix a loss of jobs.”
For rental properties, it’s also worth distinguishing between improvements that could increase rent or reduce future maintenance and upgrades that simply make the property nicer. Over-improving can eat into returns without necessarily producing comparable additional income.
6. Financing can change the entire deal
The purchase price isn’t the only number that determines affordability. Your interest rate, down payment, closing costs, loan terms, and required reserves can significantly affect both your upfront investment and ongoing cash flow.
Investment property financing can also come with different requirements than financing a primary residence. Depending on the loan, property type, and borrower, lenders may require a larger down payment, additional cash reserves, or different qualification standards. Those requirements can affect both how much cash you need upfront and how the property performs once financing costs are included.
Explore financing before becoming attached to a particular property. Different investment strategies and property types may also have different financing considerations, so understanding your options early can help you establish a realistic budget.
Most importantly, avoid stretching your finances so far to acquire the property that you have little cash left for repairs, vacancies, or other surprises.
7. Owning an investment property can be more hands-on than expected
Investment properties can generate income, but they also require management. Rental owners may need to advertise vacancies, screen applicants, coordinate repairs, maintain records, collect rent, and respond when something goes wrong.
Before buying, think realistically about how involved you want to be. If you plan to hire a property manager or other professionals, include those costs when analyzing the deal rather than treating them as an afterthought.
>>Read: 6 Common Every First-Time Landlord Should Avoid
8. Your network and education matter more than you might think
Real estate investing comes with a learning curve, so it can help to understand the basics before buying your first property.
“Set a reasonable education budget early; you don’t need to rack up debt or spend thousands of dollars to learn how to invest,” emphasizes Shirley Henderson, president and co-founder of the Real Estate Investors Association of Washington. “Focus your education dollars on practical tools you’ll actually use, including due diligence, evaluating properties, what to look for and avoid, and determining whether the numbers work. Connect with experienced investors and build your professional teams through your local REIA; you may also find Member benefits that save you money on services you’ll need as you get started.”
Connecting with other local investors can give you valuable firsthand knowledge about neighborhoods, contractors, local regulations, common expenses, and challenges that are difficult to uncover through online research alone.
The bottom line: Prepare for more than the best-case scenario
Perhaps the most important thing to know before buying an investment property is that a deal shouldn’t depend on everything going perfectly. Before committing, understand your strategy, run realistic numbers, research the local market, and consider how the investment would perform if income falls or expenses rise. You may not be able to anticipate every challenge, but planning for different outcomes can put you in a stronger position if something unexpected comes up.
Get prequalified for your dream home
Our partner Rocket Mortgage® delivers award-winning service, fast pre-approvals, and seamless closings. Rocket Mortgage is an affiliate of Redfin. You aren’t required to use its lending services. Learn more at redfin.com/afba.
See if you qualifyWhat to know before buying an investment property: FAQs
What expenses should I account for when buying an investment property?
In addition to the mortgage, consider property taxes, insurance, maintenance, repairs, utilities, HOA dues, property management, vacancy periods, renovations, and other recurring or unexpected costs. The exact expenses will depend on the property and how you plan to use it.
How do I know if an investment property makes financial sense?
Look at the full picture rather than the purchase price alone. Compare expected income with financing costs, taxes, insurance, maintenance, vacancies, management expenses, and any planned renovations. It can also help to consider how the numbers would look if income is lower or expenses are higher than expected.
Do I need a property manager for an investment property?
Not necessarily. Some owners manage rental properties themselves, while others hire a property manager to handle tasks such as marketing vacancies, screening applicants, collecting rent, coordinating repairs, and maintaining records. If you plan to hire one, include that cost when evaluating the investment.
>>Read: How to Set Up a Rental Property
What should I research before buying an investment property?
Research the local housing and rental market, comparable rents and sales, property taxes, insurance costs, vacancy trends, local regulations, permitting requirements, and any rules that could affect how you plan to use the property. You should also evaluate the property’s condition and understand your financing options before moving forward.
What should I know before buying my first investment property?
Start with a clear investment strategy and realistic budget. Understand the property’s expected income and expenses, research the local market, account for financing and renovation costs, and leave room for unexpected repairs or vacancies. It can also help to build a network of local professionals and experienced investors before you buy.
